Why Hindustan Zinc Shares Are Falling: Silver Connection Explained

Rahul Asati Image

Rahul Asati

Last updated:
9 min read
image with title "Why Hindustan Zinc Shares Are Falling The Silver Connection Explained"
Table Of Contents
  • Why Is Hindustan Zinc Share Price Falling?
  • How Is Hindustan Zinc Connected to Silver?
  • How Much Can Falling Silver Prices Impact Hindustan Zinc's Profit?
  • Why Did Hindustan Zinc's Silver Revenue Increase Despite Falling Prices?
  • Why Falling Silver Prices Can Hurt Hindustan Zinc but Help Solar Companies
  • Hindustan Zinc Announces ₹80,000 Crore Expansion
  • What Should Hindustan Zinc Investors Watch?
  • Author's Take

Hindustan Zinc shares have fallen around 7% in the last five trading sessions, mainly due to falling silver prices.

MCX silver futures fell to around ₹1.6 lakh per kg as a stronger US dollar and concerns over higher US interest rates put pressure on silver prices.

But why is falling silver a problem for Hindustan Zinc, a company primarily known for producing zinc? The answer lies in its earnings.

Let's understand the connection between Hindustan Zinc and silver, how falling prices affect its earnings, and what investors should watch.

Why Is Hindustan Zinc Share Price Falling?

Hindustan Zinc's recent decline comes amid weakness in silver prices and broader selling pressure across metal stocks.

Nifty Metal index also came under pressure as investors reacted to falling commodity prices, a stronger US dollar and expectations of higher interest rates in the US.

Higher interest rates generally make precious metals less attractive because assets such as silver do not generate regular interest income. A stronger dollar can also put pressure on international silver prices.

For Hindustan Zinc, this matters because the company earns a significant portion of its profit from silver. When silver prices decline, investors may expect lower earnings from the company in upcoming quarters.

However, silver is not the only factor affecting Hindustan Zinc's share price. Zinc prices, production costs, global metal demand and the company's expansion plans also influence investor expectations.

How Is Hindustan Zinc Connected to Silver?

Hindustan Zinc is one of the world's largest integrated zinc producers. However, it is also among the world's top silver producers.

The interesting part is that Hindustan Zinc does not primarily mine silver separately. Instead, silver is recovered as a by-product during its zinc and lead mining and processing operations.

In simple terms, when Hindustan Zinc extracts and processes ores containing zinc and lead, it can also recover silver from them.

This gives the company an advantage because it can generate revenue from multiple metals using shared mining and processing infrastructure.

But it also means the company's profitability is influenced by silver prices, even though zinc remains its primary business.

Silver Contributes 43% of Hindustan Zinc's Segment Profit

The importance of silver becomes clear when we look at Hindustan Zinc's Q2 FY27 performance.

ParticularsSilver's contribution in Q2 FY27
Silver revenue₹4,111 crore
Share of segment revenueAround 27% to 28%
Silver segment EBIT₹3,609 crore
Share of total segment EBIT43%

 

Silver segment EBIT margin

Around 88%

EBIT refers to earnings before interest and taxes. The segment margin should not be confused with the company's overall net profit margin.

The numbers reveal something interesting. Although silver contributed less than 30% of segment revenue, it accounted for around 43% of segment operating profit.

This means silver generates a disproportionately large share of Hindustan Zinc's profit compared with its revenue contribution.

That is why Hindustan Zinc is not just a zinc-price story. Its earnings are also highly sensitive to movements in silver prices.

How Much Can Falling Silver Prices Impact Hindustan Zinc's Profit?

The impact of silver prices on Hindustan Zinc's earnings can be significant.

According to the company's commodity-price sensitivity estimates, every $1 per troy ounce change in silver prices can affect its annual EBITDA by approximately ₹200 crore to ₹225 crore.

EBITDA is a measure of operating earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation.

For example, if silver prices decline by $5 per ounce and remain at those lower levels throughout the year, the estimated impact on annual EBITDA could be around ₹1,000 crore to ₹1,125 crore, assuming other factors remain unchanged.

Here is how different silver-price movements could affect earnings.

Sustained fall in silver priceEstimated annual EBITDA reduction
$1 per ounce₹200 to ₹225 crore
$5 per ounce₹1,000 to ₹1,125 crore
$10 per ounce₹2,000 to ₹2,250 crore
$15 per ounce₹3,000 to ₹3,375 crore

These are illustrative calculations based on the company's reported sensitivity estimates, not forecasts of actual profit declines.

The actual impact will depend on several factors, including silver production, sales volumes, exchange rates and any price hedging.

Nevertheless, the sensitivity explains why investors react strongly to changes in silver prices.

Even if Hindustan Zinc continues producing the same quantity of silver, lower selling prices could reduce its revenue and profit.

Why Did Hindustan Zinc's Silver Revenue Increase Despite Falling Prices?

Interestingly, Hindustan Zinc's latest quarterly results show that falling silver prices do not always lead to lower revenue.

In Q2 FY27, the company reported silver revenue of ₹4,111 crore, an increase of 141% compared with the same quarter last year.

Even more interestingly, silver revenue increased by 7% compared with the previous quarter despite lower realised prices.

How did this happen?

The answer lies in higher sales volumes.

During Q2 FY27, Hindustan Zinc's silver sales volumes increased by around 16% sequentially, while realised silver prices declined by approximately 14%.

The increase in the quantity of silver sold helped offset the impact of lower selling prices.

This reveals an important distinction between silver-price movements and the company's actual financial performance.

Falling silver prices do not automatically mean Hindustan Zinc's revenue will decline. Higher production and sales volumes can help offset the impact.

However, there is a limitation to this strategy. Mining production cannot increase indefinitely, and higher volumes may not always compensate for a sharp or prolonged decline in prices.

For investors, the important question is whether Hindustan Zinc can maintain higher silver production while protecting its profit margins.

Why Falling Silver Prices Can Hurt Hindustan Zinc but Help Solar Companies

There is another interesting connection between silver prices and the stock market.

Silver is widely used in solar cells because of its high electrical conductivity. This makes it an important raw material for parts of the solar manufacturing industry.

For Hindustan Zinc, silver is a product that generates revenue. For solar cell manufacturers, it is an input cost. This creates an opposite relationship with silver prices.

BusinessPossible impact of falling silver prices
Hindustan ZincLower silver selling prices may reduce revenue and margins
Solar cell manufacturersLower raw material costs may improve profitability
Solar module manufacturersPotential cost benefits depending on sourcing and manufacturing processes
Silver investorsA decline in silver prices reduces the market value of their holdings

For example, when silver prices decline, a solar cell manufacturer may be able to purchase silver at lower prices.

If the company maintains its product selling prices, this could improve its margins.

However, the benefit is not guaranteed because it also depends on inventory costs, contracts and competition.

This explains why the same commodity-price movement can have different effects on companies operating at different stages of the supply chain.

Hindustan Zinc Announces ₹80,000 Crore Expansion

Amid the weakness in silver prices, Hindustan Zinc has announced a major expansion plan.

On November 16, 2026, the company's board approved its HZL 2.0 growth programme, involving an investment of approximately ₹80,000 crore over the next three to five years.

The objective is to substantially increase the company's zinc and silver production capacity.

ParticularsExisting capacityPlanned capacity
Refined metal production1.1 million tonnes annually2 million tonnes annually
Silver refining800 tonnes annually1,500 tonnes annually
Planned investment ₹80,000 crore
Expansion period 3 to 5 years

The expansion could help Hindustan Zinc increase production volumes and strengthen its position in the global zinc and silver markets.

However, the announcement has not eliminated near-term concerns surrounding the stock. There are two important reasons.

First, the expansion will take several years to complete. Any additional production and earnings from these projects will depend on their commissioning and utilisation.

Second, higher production does not necessarily translate into higher profits if metal prices decline significantly.

For example, even if Hindustan Zinc eventually produces more silver, the earnings benefit will depend on the prices at which that additional silver is sold.

There is also the investment requirement. An ₹80,000 crore expansion involves substantial capital spending, making project execution, funding and future returns important factors for investors.

In other words, the company's long-term production plans may look promising, but its near-term earnings remain exposed to fluctuations in commodity prices.

What Should Hindustan Zinc Investors Watch?

The recent correction highlights why investors should look beyond Hindustan Zinc's zinc business when evaluating the company.

  • Silver prices and earnings sensitivity: Silver contributed 43% of segment operating profit in Q2 FY27. A prolonged decline in silver prices could affect future profitability, even if production remains stable.
  • Silver production and sales volumes: Higher sales volumes helped Hindustan Zinc grow its silver revenue despite lower prices in Q2 FY27. Investors can track whether this trend continues.
  • Zinc prices and production costs: Zinc remains the company's largest revenue contributor. In Q2 FY27, its zinc production cost declined to $703 per tonne, providing some support to profitability. However, future margins will also depend on zinc selling prices.
  • Expansion execution: Hindustan Zinc's ₹80,000 crore investment programme could significantly increase production capacity. The timelines, actual spending and returns from these projects will determine how much value the expansion creates.
  • Earnings expectations: Hindustan Zinc reported strong Q2 FY27 results, with net profit increasing 142% year-on-year to ₹6,412 crore. The key question is how much of that profitability can be sustained if silver and other commodity prices remain under pressure.

Author's Take

Hindustan Zinc's recent share-price decline highlights something that is easy to overlook. Although the company is primarily associated with zinc, silver has become a major contributor to its profitability.

With silver accounting for around 43% of segment operating profit, changes in silver prices can have a substantial impact on the company's earnings.

However, the relationship is not entirely straightforward. Hindustan Zinc demonstrated in Q2 FY27 that higher sales volumes can offset lower realised silver prices. Its lower zinc production costs also provide some protection against commodity-price weakness.

The ₹80,000 crore expansion adds another dimension to the story. It could support higher production over the longer term, but also requires significant investment while leaving the company exposed to future metal prices.

For investors, the bigger question is not simply whether silver prices will recover. It is whether Hindustan Zinc can maintain its profitability through higher production, cost efficiency and expansion, even if silver prices remain volatile.

Ultimately, Hindustan Zinc's earnings depend not only on how much metal it produces, but also on the prices at which it can sell that metal.

Share: