- 1. The Performance Check (What the Data Says)
- 2. The "Defensive" Strategy
- 3. Why Does It Lag in Rallies? (The Cash Factor)
- 4. Stock Selection Style: Bottom-Up vs. Top-Down
- Conclusion
If you are a mutual fund investor, you have likely heard of the SBI Small Cap Fund. It is one of the giants in the industry, currently the third-largest small-cap fund by size (AUM).
However, recent data shows that its returns have been lower compared to its peers. Why is a fund that was once a favourite now lagging?
Let’s look at the data and the strategy behind this fund to understand what is happening.
1. The Performance Check (What the Data Says)
First, let’s compare SBI Small Cap with other top funds in the same category based on the latest data:
| Fund Name | 1-Year Return | 3-Year Return | 5-Year Return | AUM (Size) |
| Nippon India Small Cap | 4.72% | 21.7% | 26.81% | ₹68,287 Cr |
| HDFC Small Cap | 8.6% | 20.68% | 24.27% | ₹37,753 Cr |
| Quant Small Cap | 1.5% | 19.58% | 28.31% | ₹29,785 Cr |
| SBI Small Cap | 0.61% | 13.86% | 18.44% | ₹36,268 Cr |
The Observation:
As you can see, SBI Small Cap has delivered the lowest returns among these top 4 funds across all time frames (1, 3, and 5 years). While Nippon and Quant gave over 26-28% in the last 5 years, SBI stands at roughly 18.44%.
2. The "Defensive" Strategy
To understand these numbers, we have to understand the fund's personality. SBI Small Cap is known as a "Defensive Fund."
This means it behaves differently depending on the market situation:
- When the Market Falls: This fund usually falls less than others. For example, in 2022, when many small-cap funds were giving negative returns, SBI Small Cap actually gave a positive 10% return. It is good at protecting your money during bad times.
- When the Market Rises: This is where it struggles. When the market rallies aggressively, this fund tends to underperform. In the 2023 rally, while some small-cap funds gave returns up to 90%, SBI Small Cap gave around 49%.
3. Why Does It Lag in Rallies? (The Cash Factor)
One big reason for the lower returns during market rallies is the fund's Cash Holding.
- What others do: Many funds follow a "Momentum" strategy. They invest almost all their money (keeping only about 5% cash) to ride the market wave.
- What SBI does: SBI follows a "Value" strategy. In 2023, the fund manager kept nearly 15% of the money in cash.
Why? The fund manager prefers to wait for the "right price." They don't want to buy expensive stocks just because the market is going up. However, holding cash in a rising market means that 15% of the portfolio is earning zero returns, which drags down the overall performance.
4. Stock Selection Style: Bottom-Up vs. Top-Down
Finally, the way SBI picks stocks is different from many peers.
- Peers (Top-Down): Many funds look for trending sectors (like Railways or Defence) and then pick stocks in those sectors. This captures fast growth.
- SBI (Bottom-Up): SBI focuses on finding fundamentally strong individual companies, regardless of whether their sector is trending or not.
Because of this, the fund often misses out on short-term sector rallies, leading to lower returns when specific sectors are booming.
Conclusion
Is SBI Small Cap a "bad" fund? No. It is simply a distinct type of fund.
The data shows that its current rolling returns are below the category average. However, this is largely because of its conservative strategy.
- If you want high-risk, high-reward performance that chases market rallies, this fund might feel slow to you.
If you prefer stability and want a fund that protects your downside when the market crashes, SBI Small Cap sticks to its core philosophy of safety over speed.
Disclaimer: The content is meant for education and general information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Mutual Funds are non-exchange traded products, and INDstocks is merely acting as a mutual fund distributor. All disputes with respect to distribution activity, would not have access to the exchange investor redressal forum or arbitration mechanism. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully before investing. INDstocks Private Limited (formerly known as INDmoney Private Limited) 616, Level 6, Suncity Success Tower, Sector 65, Gurugram, 122005, SEBI Stock Broking Registration No: INZ000305337, Trading and Clearing Member of NSE (90267, M70042) and BSE, BSE StarMF (6779), AMFI Registration No: ARN-254564, SEBI Depository Participant Reg. No. IN-DP-690-2022, Depository Participant ID: CDSL 12095500, Research Analyst Registration No. INH000018948 BSE RA Enlistment No. 6428.