Can Silver Give Negative Returns? 8 Negative Years in the last 16

Most people think of silver as a “safe” asset. Something that should steadily go up over time. But the year-to-year reality is very different. In the last 16 years, silver gave negative returns in 8 years. That means it lost money in 1 out of every 2 years.

In this blog, you will learn what the year-by-year numbers really say, why silver swings so sharply, and how to read these returns like a practical retail investor.

What the Year-by-Year Data Really Shows

The simplest way to understand silver is to look at it one year at a time. The last 16 years show a clear pattern: silver does not move in a straight line.

Here are the year-on-year returns of silver:

Source: Goodreturns, Bankbazaar

Silver returns were negative in 2022 (−12%), 2021 (−1%), 2019 (−2%), 2016 (−2%), 2015 (−12%), 2014 (−20%), 2013 (−4%), and 2012 (−1%). That is 8 negative years out of 16.

At the same time, silver can suddenly surge. It gave 109% returns in 2011, 56% in 2020, and a stunning 163% in 2025. These are not small moves. They are the kind of moves that can change outcomes quickly, both positively and negatively.

The big message is simple. Silver can create wealth in some years, and destroy it in others. If someone expects silver to behave like a steady savings instrument, this table is a reality check.

Why Silver Swings So Sharply

Silver is often spoken about in the same breath as gold because both are “precious metals” and both are traded globally. But silver is not priced only like a safe-haven asset. Around 55-60% of global silver demand now comes from industrial uses, so it also behaves like an industrial commodity.

That “double identity” is the core reason for sharp swings. When the global economy looks strong, investors expect higher factory activity, and silver can rise with that optimism. When growth worries show up, those expectations can cool fast, and silver can fall.

Silver also reacts to inflation and interest rates. If markets start expecting higher inflation or lower real returns, metals can get a boost. If rates rise or the US dollar strengthens, silver can face pressure.

Finally, silver is a smaller market than gold, so trading flows can move the price more. When speculation picks up, silver’s moves often look bigger in both directions, which is why you can see extreme years like +163% and −20%.

How Investors Should Read These Numbers

For a normal investor, the most important takeaway is not the best year. It is the frequency of bad years. If silver loses money in 8 out of 16 years, it is not designed to deliver comfort every calendar year.

This is why silver is often better understood as a diversifier (an asset that behaves differently from your main investments), so the total portfolio swings can be reduced. Silver can sometimes help when other assets struggle, but it can also fall at the same time.

These numbers also highlight expectation setting. If someone buys silver after a big year like 2025 (+163%), the next year may not repeat that performance. Returns tend to be uneven. A sharp rise can be followed by a flat year or a negative year, simply because markets cool off or conditions change.

So, instead of asking “Will silver go up?”, the more useful question is: “Can I handle a bad year in silver without panic selling?” Because historically, bad years are not rare. They are part of the package.

What Retail Investors Should Know

Silver can be useful, but it demands emotional discipline and clear expectations. The year-by-year record shows that patience alone does not guarantee a smooth ride.

• Negative years are common: 8 out of 16 years were below 
• Big gains can come suddenly, but so can sharp cuts
• Double-digit losses happened in 4 separate years since 2010
• One-year returns can mislead if viewed in isolation
• Volatility is normal in silver, not an exception

If you track silver, focus on what role it plays in your overall financial plan. The numbers suggest it behaves more like a high-swing asset than a stable store of yearly returns.

Final Word

Silver often feels familiar in India. It is visible in households, gifts, and jewellery counters. That familiarity can create a false sense of stability. But the return history tells a more balanced story. Over the last 16 years, silver delivered negative returns in 8 years, so losing years are not a surprise event.

At the same time, silver can be spectacular in certain phases. The data that shows −20% in 2014 also shows +109% in 2011 and +163% in 2025. That range is the definition of a volatile asset.

For retail investors, the real value of this data is clarity. Silver can sometimes protect, sometimes outperform, and sometimes disappoint. It is not a smooth, linear wealth creator. If you treat it as a steady yearly performer, the negative years can feel confusing. If you treat it as an asset that swings with global cycles, the same numbers start making sense. The goal is not to fear silver. It is to understand what it can realistically do, year after year.

Disclaimer

Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. The securities are quoted as an example and not as a recommendation. This is nowhere to be considered as advice, recommendation, or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell or subscribe for securities. INDStocks SIP / Mini Save is a SIP feature that enables Customer(s) to save a fixed amount on a daily basis to invest in Indian stocks. INDstocks Private Limited (formerly known as INDmoney Private Limited) 616, Level 6, Suncity Success Tower, Sector 65, Gurugram, 122005, SEBI Stock Broking Registration No: INZ000305337, Trading and Clearing Member of NSE (90267, M70042) and BSE, BSE StarMF (6779), SEBI Depository Participant Reg. No. IN-DP-690-2022, Depository Participant ID: CDSL 12095500, Research Analyst Registration No. INH000018948 BSE RA Enlistment No. 6428. Refer to https://indstocks.com/pricing?type=indian-stocks; https://www.indstocks.com/page/indian-stocks-sip-terms-and-condition for further details.